New This Week
Critics & Publications
Archives: A-Z Index
Advanced Search

Upcoming Release Calendar
Awards & Bests By Year
All-Time High Scores
All-Time Low Scores
How Metascores Are Calculated
Discuss Film In Our Forums

sort by name

sort by score

17 88 Minutes
55 Baby Mama
78 Before I Forget
80 Bigger, Stronger, Faster*
75 Boy A
32 Chapter 27
54 CSNY: Déjà Vu
31 Deception
64 Fall, The
51 Finding Amanda
57 Forbidden Kingdom, The
67 Forgetting Sarah Marshall
34 Happening, The
27 How to Rob a Bank
79 Iron Man
46 Jack Brooks: Monster Slayer
62 Kabluey
56 Leatherheads
72 Lou Reed's Berlin
24 Love Guru, The
37 Made of Honor
65 Married Life
52 Mother of Tears, The
70 Outsourced
83 Paranoid Park
55 Pathology
22 Postal
51 Promotion, The
77 Rape of Europa, The
69 Redbelt
48 Run, Fat Boy, Run
30 Sarah Landon and the Paranormal Hour
53 Sex and the City: The Movie
67 Snow Angels
66 Son of Rambow
37 Speed Racer
82 Taxi to the Dark Side
56 Then She Found Me
79 Visitor, The
65 Water Lilies
36 What Happens in Vegas...
45 Where in the World Is Osama Bin Laden?
54 You Don't Mess with the Zohan
75 Young@Heart

Stars indicate the most critically-acclaimed movies.

Under the Same Moon
Fox Searchlight Pictures, The Weinstein Company


9.4

based on 24 reviews
Read critic reviews
How did we calculate this?

based on 27 votes
Read user comments
Rate this movie

MPAA RATING: PG-13 for some mature thematic elements

Starring Kate Del Castillo, Adrian Alonso, Jesse Garcia, Kate del Castillo, Eugenio Derbez, Maya Zapata, and Carmen Salinas

When the death of his grandmother leaves young Carlitos alone, he takes his fate into his own hands and heads north across the border to find his mother. As he journeys from his rural Mexican village to the L.A. barrio, Carlitos faces seemingly insurmountable obstacles with a steely determination and unfettered optimism that earn him the grudging respect and affection of a reluctant protector, a middle-aged migrant worker named Enrique. The unlikely pair finds their way from Tucson to East L.A., but the only clue Carlitos has to his mother's whereabouts is her description of the street corner from which she has called him each Sunday for the last four years. Unaware that Rosario is just hours away from returning to Mexico to be with her son, Carlitos and Enrique desperately comb the vast, unfamiliar city for a place he has seen only in his imagination. (Fox Searchlight)

GENRE(S):	Drama
WRITTEN BY:	Ligiah Villalobos
DIRECTED BY:	Patricia Riggen
RELEASE DATE:	DVD: June 17, 2008 Theatrical: March 19, 2008
RUNNING TIME:	109 minutes, Color
ORIGIN:	Mexico / USA
LANGUAGE(S):	English / Spanish

All critic scores are converted to a 100-point scale. If a critic does not indicate a score, we assign a score based on the general impression given by the text of the review. Learn more...

Entertainment Weekly Owen Gleiberman

The film says that the U.S. immigrant situation is untenable, but then it forces US to ask: What should be done?

TV Guide Ken Fox

It's an unexpectedly powerful little film that manages to say a lot of what, despite all the talk on the subject, isn't being said in the national debate on immigration.

Washington Post Ann Hornaday

Thanks to the uncommonly shrewd judgment of screenwriter Ligiah Villalobos and director Patricia Riggen, both newcomers, the film never feels like rank exploitation, even as it steadily aims for the emotional jugular.

USA Today Claudia Puig

A powerful and evocative account of the efforts undertaken to forge a perilous mother-and-child reunion. Told in Spanish with English subtitles, it is a moving tale of yearning, as well as unflagging courage and determination.

San Francisco Chronicle Ruthe Stein

Although based on a fictional story, it has the feel of truth and is a vivid reminder of the hell Mexicans put themselves through to live in the United States, even illegally.

Miami Herald Rene Rodriguez

Instead of delivering a pointed statement, this timely and energetic crowd-pleaser aims for -- and accomplishes -- something much more difficult: It makes you fall in love with its characters.

ReelViews James Berardinelli

The strong final third counterbalances the weaknesses of the first half. I prefer films that build to something worthwhile rather than collapse short of the finish line.

Boston Globe Ty Burr

The result is a genuinely cathartic night at the movies - which is one of the reasons we go to them in the first place. Art it ain't, but popcorn is rarely this skilled or seductive.

Charlotte Observer Lawrence Toppman

It takes place on both sides of the U.S./Mexico border, and it offers an undeniable argument that life without love is unpalatable on either side.

Portland Oregonian Grant Butler

First-time director Patricia Riggen uses parallel story lines to tell the mother's and son's tales...It's a storytelling technique that's meant to emphasize how mother and son are utterly unaware of the other's struggles, but instead it robs the plot of tension, making the inevitable reunion seem schmaltzy.

Christian Science Monitor Peter Rainer

The filmmakers are smart enough – or cynical enough – to realize that we don't watch movies like Under the Same Moon in order to be surprised. We go to them for a good cry.

Austin Chronicle Josh Rosenblatt

Its parallel stories of two lost souls seeking each other across geographical divides is never more than one small step away from mawkishness and cliché, and oftentimes less.

Philadelphia Inquirer Steven Rea

How do you say "tearjerker" in Spanish?

Premiere Glenn Kenny

Accomplished and well-intentioned to the extent that one wants to accentuate the positive, but the positive isn't the whole, alas; for every moment in the film that evokes classic neo-realism, there's another that's commonplace or overly sentimental.

Chicago Tribune Michael Phillips

An estimated 4 million Latinas leave one or more children behind when they travel north to find work. They deserve a more nuanced film, but this one’s often affecting.

The Globe and Mail (Toronto) Stephen Cole

If Under the Same Moon is formula melodrama, the film is well acted and its lead character perceptively drawn.

The Onion (A.V. Club) Tasha Robinson

A harmless feel-good movie that tries to tell audiences what it's like to be a victimized immigrant, and mostly winds up telling them what it's like to have their heartstrings yanked, gratuitiously and often.

Seattle Post-Intelligencer Sean Axmaker

For all the clumsy scenes and cloying performances, director Patricia Riggen puts her adults through tough choices and hard consequences.

Wall Street Journal Joe Morgenstern

Under the Same Moon comes most vividly to life when Adrian Alonso is on the screen.

Los Angeles Times Kenneth Turan

This largely Spanish-language film brings on the waterworks because its core story is undeniably affecting. The whole movie, however, would be more convincing if the elements around that vital core were more multidimensional and less contrived.

Variety Justin Chang

Wrapping the political hot potato of illegal immigration in the sentimental balm of a mother-son reunion drama, this stirring tale will be embraced most enthusiastically by Mexican audiences on both sides of the border.

Village Voice Michelle Orange

The duo's travels never gain a traction of their own, and the film's destination feels overdetermined despite its sweetness.

The New York Times Jeannette Catsoulis

This is screenwriting by numbers. Unlike, say, Ken Loach’s marvelous “Bread and Roses,” Under the Same Moon is too busy sanctifying its protagonists and prodding our tear ducts to say anything remotely novel about immigration policies or their helpless victims.

Chicago Reader Jonathan Rosenbaum

Your enjoyment of this picaresque tearjerker may depend on how much you can tolerate its shameless contrivances and didactic social realism, whereby the story exists only to illustrate the plight of illegal aliens. I was ultimately more moved than appalled, but it was a close contest.

The average user rating for this movie is 9.4 (out of 10) based on 27 User Votes
Note: User votes are NOT included in the Metascore calculation.

Ram b. gave it an8:
If this movie is about immigration, then Star Wars is a documentary about outer space exploration. This is a shameless tearjerker about family, friendship, love, and transformation. The movie is predictable. But in this unpredictable world, it what makes it also fun and comfortable to watch. Message: although the world out there is ugly, still there is some love... Is what you want to watch once in a while after reading the news? Also the kid's acting is amazing.

Julie R. gave it a9:
I don't care if I was a bit emotionally manipulated. I loved this movie with a happy ending. The audience at the theatre clapped at the end - that says a lot!!!

Gloria G. gave it a10:
Surely one of my favorites for this 2008 !, a smart script, good actings, bravo México!.

Chad S. gave it a7:
We love plucky children. And Carlitos(Adrian Alonso) has pluck. We also love to sympathize with mothers who make sacrifices for their children. Carlitos was five the last time Rosario(Kate del Castillo) tucked her son into bed. He's nine, now. "Misma luna, La" speaks to our love for plucky kids and their self-sacrificing moms. It sidesteps, however, our attitude towards illegal border crossers who aren't cute and charismatic cherubs, or milfs with smoldering eyes. If "Misma luna, La" was serious about making its case about a Mexican's right to live in the states, Enrique(Eugenio Derbez) should've just walked on by. You like him, yes, because he performed a heroic deed. Your moviegoing-self might even be a little sad about his impending departure. Meanwhile, your real world-self feels a sense of satisfaction that this unskilled laborer will be deported back to the other Los Angeles on the other side of our country. A film such as Ken Loach's "Bread and Roses", or a novel like "Highwire Days" by Susan Straight, doesn't make hypocrites out of its viewers, or readers. With little, or no shameless manipulation, both movie and book made you confront your actual capacity for clemency, or none to speak of, in some cases, towards our neighbors to the south. But "Misma luna, La" shouldn't be penalized for what it isn't. It's just a crowd-pleaser. And does it please? Yes. Bottom line: we're rooting for a mother and child reunion.

Greg D. gave it a9:
It may be a "gratuitous" tear-jerker, but as those movies go, it's fantastic. Adrian Alonso is positively incredible.

Lucy P. D. gave it a10:
I can see some critics give a low rate altough they express many good things they found in the movie... a teerjerker movie is somthing bad?, they want more blood?, violent movies?, more "no happy endings " finals to give awards?...anyway, I enjoyed a lot this great movie, I love it!.

Chelly V. gave it a10:
Hi !, I just wanna add that this movie worths every minute you pay for see it, like no one other movie did it last year ( except ratatouille ) this touch your heart in a special way, is completely honest and you want to see more when u you see...the end.

Under the Same Moon Fox Searchlight Pictures, The Weinstein Company

Under the Same Moon
Fox Searchlight Pictures, The Weinstein Company